How To Avoid Mistakes When Hiring Temp Employees - Stabene
Wednesday, September 23, 2020
Business & Finance

How To Avoid Mistakes When Hiring Temp Employees


According to the American Staffing Association, America’s staffing companies hire almost 17 million temporary and contract employees each year. Clearly there is a significant need for temporary staffing around the country. 

However, the stories of temporary hiring woes—from legal nightmares to pot-smoking temp. salesman—can leave employers who need temporary assistance gun shy about moving forward with hires. 

With that in mind today we are going to discuss how to avoid hiring mistakes when it comes to temporary employees.

Be Clear About Expectations 

One of the worst mistakes many companies make when hiring temporary employees is they aren’t clear about the expectations for the job.

Too often employers will either blatantly lie to or lead on temporary hires about what their role is going to be at the company, only for them to find all they are going to do is cold calls, or punch numbers into Excel spreadsheets. Remember, temporary employees aren’t going to be motivated to help you if you are lying to them the very first time you meet.

If this sounds like something you’ve done in the past, you might want to stop. The fact is lying to employees, especially if the information is written in a contract, is a dangerous business. You may end up being legally liable for falsifying a contract, but even if you escape legal consequences, there will certainly be bad business reviews on Google reviews, Glassdoor, etc. and that can hurt your chances of hiring quality full-time employees in the future. 

Lying About Contract Extensions

Also, don’t lead temporary employees on in regards to the potential for them to become full-time employees at the end of their contract. Not only is this an unethical business practice. It can bad business reviews or at minimum a disgruntled employee. 

Simply put, don’t lie to your employees, temporary or otherwise. Instead, try treating your temporary employees like human beings. It’s really sad that I have to write this, but after reading countless stories of temporary employees being treated like dogs, I definitely have to.

Just listen to this tragic story from Marilyn Weinstein, founder and CEO of Vivo: 

“One of our consultants told us stories of not being allowed to eat birthday cake during when it’s a team member’s birthday. HR at that company makes them stay at their desks, while the rest of the team gathered to celebrate. “This would be a blurring of the lines,” their HR tells them.”

So please, let your temps have cake, treat them like you would any other employee because if you don’t, it’s not only bad for your business, but it may also lead to legal action. This isn’t the 1850’s. Workers have rights. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) applies to temp employees just as it does to full-time employees. Too many employers have lost thousands of dollars simply because they weren’t willing to extend professional courtesy and be honest with their temporary hires.

Make A Pre-Hire Checklist

Temporary employees can be great additions to your team, or they can be complete nightmares that add nothing but more work and stress. 

If you make enough hires you will eventually run into a temp that just doesn’t cut it, but that’s not a big deal, what can really cause you problems is when a temp is looking for a payday through a lawsuit or by receiving unemployment. 

This is why it’s so important to make a pre-hire checklist to protect yourself from those bad eggs out there. From job assessments to asses applicants’ real skills(not just the ones they claim to have on their resume) to non-disclosure agreements to protect yourself from intellectual property theft, having a solid pre-hire checklist is vital if you are going to hire a temp employee without fear.

Here is an example pre-hire checklist of ‘To-Do’s’ before making a hire:

  • Run a background check
  • Run a drug screening
  • Require two forms of identification
  • Have every staff member, temp or otherwise, sign an employment contract
  • Ask for and keep copies of all certificates or licenses
  • Ask for proof of residence
  • Ask for at least two references
  • Sign non-disclosure agreements(if necessary)
  • Give a qualified job fit assessment
  • Have two in-person interviews

Of course, all of the points on this checklist are time-consuming and costly.  Many employers simply don’t have the time to navigate the hiring process the right way. 

Thankfully, there is another option. 

You Can Hire A Recruiter

Why not hire a contract recruiter who specializes in finding quality, pre-vetted temporary hires?

Don’t listen to me though, here’s Frances Moreno, CPA and founder of Vaco Los Angeles elaborating why she believes ‘cheaping out’ when it comes to hiring just isn’t the way to go:

“(a big mistake in temp hiring is)Trying to go inexpensively and be a do it yourself-er. Strategic staffing doesn’t have to be expensive; however, you do need to pay market rates and rely on people who are highly skilled in providing this labor. Companies that hire temporary workers should partner with a reputable service that works with long-term contractors, consultants, and temporary professionals.”

The reality is the best way to avoid mistakes when hiring temporary employees is to outsource the process. From background checks to drug tests and even interviews, temporary staffing firms can help make the process painless and worry-free. 

If you can afford their services, it’s the way to go. Not only will you save time and stress less, but you can end up saving money too, by avoiding lawsuits and hiring mistakes that prevent your business from running smoothly. 

So if you’re looking to avoid having your own stories of temp. hires gone bad, be honest, follow your check-list, or simply outsource hiring to the professionals.

Leave a Reply